What do you do when you get handed the opportunity to be one of the rare few to attend a preview of one of the most anticipated films of the year? You drop everything you are doing, nod your head in acceptance and ask three questions... When, where and what time? And that is exactly what I did. I hauled my butt across London in the snow to make sure I got a sneak peek of Rajkumar Hirani's latest offering 3 Idiots (3I).
My journey across London actually came to be quite useful. It gave me time to think about the film. What were my expectations from a film that boasted Hirani at the helm as director, Vidhu Vinod Chopra as producer and was going to be Aamir Khan's only release of the year; and that too amongst rumours that of Aamir Khan taking a break from films? So if I said that my expectations were high, I think you would all understand. I mean take a look at their records -; they speak for themselves really.
So what happens when you bring together 3 perfectionists to work on a project that is loosely based on a Chetan Bhagat book? Well a film called 3 Idiots happens. Without giving too much away, on the surface 3I is a film about 2 friends Farhan Quershi (R. Madhavan) and Raju Rastogi (Sharman Joshi) on a journey across India looking for their missing friend Ranncchoddas Shamalaldas Chancha aka Rancho (Aamir Khan). It is during this journey that Farhan and Raju take a walk down memory lane. Relayed to the audience mostly through flashback and narrated by Farhan, the memories take the audience through the decisive moments that shaped the characters backgrounds, personalities and relationships as well as define the friendship the three lead characters develop and share. And it is the development of this friendship and their antics that will keep you rooted to your seat.
Before watching the film I had a couple of major concerns; one of them was Aamir Khan essaying the role of a college student; a forty-four year old playing the role of a twenty – something. Having seen the film I realised what an IDIOT I was. Aamir is a known perfectionist, and Aamir as the non-conforming Rancho is perfect. The image Aamir Khan developed for Ghajini over a year ago is non–existent. The bulging eyes, the introverted nature, the intensity, the anger waiting to unfurl: All gone. Sanjay Singhania is replaced by Rancho's wide-eyed innocence. Aamir Khan manages to once again get into the head of the character he is playing and successfully breathes life in to the free spirited and honest Rancho; it actually takes a moment for you to digest the difference in appearance and character undertaken by Khan. It is his attention to detail that really some through in 3I. The big, baggy, oversized clothing worn by Aamir makes him look tiny and at time incredibly vulnerable. The characters constant movement, the wide-eyed excitement of a twenty something year old, the curiosity to learn – if there was an actor who could pull this off, it could only be Aamir. And he does with great aplomb.
Madhavan and Joshi give consistent performances throughout the film. Both have fantastic comic timing and are the perfect compliment to Khan's Rancho. A few moments do stand out more than others, Madhavan's expression whilst eating dinner at Raju's, and then later on when he is caught out with his friends at a wedding are fantastic. Similarly, his expressions when Rancho almost marries him off to Raju's sister Kammo are brilliant. Sharman's expressions too while providing the background score during his friend's declaration of love and then later on when he has to choose between his friend and his education really stand out. These scenes standout in their subtlety but leave a lasting impression.
Kareena Kapoor, it seems, is out to give Emraan Hashmi competition in the kissing stakes. As Pia she is good, but I don't think she bought anything to the character that couldn't be bought by someone else. I can easily picture Deepika Padukone, Geneilia D'Souza in the role.
The chemistry shared by the new on –screen jodi is okay, nothing to shout about but as a jodi they work. Would I want to see the jodi repeated? I am not sure yet. I haven't quite decided; this maybe due to the simple fact that in a film where the monopoly is held by the 3 Idiots there really isn't enough time to focus on a love story. However, where I am uncertain of wanting a repeat of the Aamir – Kareena jodi, I am 100% certain that I would want the Aamir–Madhavan–Sharman chemistry repeated. The chemistry between the three is fantastic and the trio are well supported by Omi as 'silencer' and Boman Irani as Viru Sahastrabuddhe, which at times is reminiscent of Munna Bhai's Dr Astana.
My second major concern was Hirani and his concept. The trailers being aired on T.V. advertised another campus based film; my concern was how Hirani would differentiate 3i from other films that are of a similar topic, i.e. friendship and student's on the path of self discovery. My conclusion was that differentiation would eventually boil down to Hirani's treatment of the subject matter.
Even though the idea is not original, Hirani's treatment is. This is mainly because Hirani has a very distinct style. The entertainer that enlightens and 3I does both. Though I haven't quite decided whether 3i is a comedy, a drama or a feel good family flick, it does manage to cover several social issues that are typical of a Hirani film. The fact that India has the highest rate of suicides within the student community, the pressures that are put on children by their parents, teachers and peers, the idea of gradism, and colleges no-longer encouraging free thinking are all explored. It is just at times it leaves you asking for more.
There are moments in 3I that take you back to MBBS, parts of the film are predictable. Some instances you can see coming a mile off, others you can begin to predict halfway through after you gain an understanding of what is going on. There is one quite well packaged surprise though.
Hirani successfully manages to set the tone and the pace of the film within the first 15 minutes. He then not only builds on this but manages to maintain pace, and for a film coming in at just under 3 hours at no point did I feel the film dragged, it could however be edited in a couple of places. Comedy is definitely Hirani's fort and there was more than one occasion where the audience laughed out loud, I think the chamatkaar/balatkaar scene drew the most. The emotional scenes were touching, but not overly so – I didn't get teary eyed at any point.
His choice to shoot in India is commended. There are some scenes that simply take your breath away, especially towards the end. It does make you wonder why directors choose to travel abroad when they have such stunning locations in India.
He also manages to give the audience 'aal izz well', the 3I version of Munna's Jadoo ki Jhappi and Gandhigiri ideology. Whether he manages to start another movement with this idea, only time will tell; it is quite an interesting idea though.
The music of the film was well used and I was impressed with Aamir Khan's subtitling of the songs. I normally try to avoid hearing the music of a film for two reasons: 1. To find out whether I feel the song interferes with the storyline wanting me to fast forward it 2. Not to raise my expectations from the choreography aspect
I can now honestly say that I would not want to skip through any of the songs and have actually had the 3I album on repeat ever since I have seen the film. All the songs are shot beautifully and do help to progress the film. Shantanu Moitra (music director), Bosco – Caesar and Avit Dias (Choreographers) have done a good job.
So was the film worth trekking in the freezing cold, facing adverse weather conditions and crappy public transport?
Yes, I have no regrets.
Would I recommend it to my friends and family?
I already have been. I plan on getting the Bhatia Khandhaan to watch it soon after its release during the Christmas break.
Did I walk away with anything after watching the film?
Yep. There is nothing wrong with being an idiot, and if you are ever in any doubt, remember 'aal izz well!'
Some parts of the movie were a bit slow for me and were making me want the movie to end. It started to pick up the pace towards the middle/end. The main actor with the beautiful eyes was great(not to mention good looking). Actually, all of the actors in that movie were very good. The message was excellent and overall an enjoyable movie to watch. I do have to agree that they had too many underware scenes that didn't need to be there. I know they were trying to make it funny, but they over did that a bit. I want to go to an Indian wedding one day, they seem so beautiful. :)
If we compare it to munna bhai then it was just nothing. Munna bhai was so decent and hilarious movie and the acting and dialogues were great. I just wanted to laugh at every dialogue of circuit. Aamir is great too but there is a difference b/w Aamir and Sanjay's class. Sanjay Dutt is an excellent actor. So no comparison b/w these 2 movies.
The delivery scene in this movie? Who would like to watch that with family especially kids. I think we are not this much advanced yet to watch such scenes with our parents or kids.
Hi.. Thanks for ur review... I have seen the film promo's.. But nothing new i found... as amir khan fan pls dnt give ur rating.. Film music is big minus.. Madhavan n Joshi r impressive since they looks really young..Amir is too old to act in dis role. Nothing to say about Kareena and Amir... Never expected like dis movie frm Amir n Kareena..
Five point someone novel narration is very better dan dis.. lets c how its goes..
Ur review is good.. but i can rate it as 2/5. Indians verdict will cm out very soon..
I really liked the movie. Apart from the fact that there was a book or that the directior made similar movies.....I think it was a funny film without being overyly dramatic. I thoroughly enjoyed myself.
Well all these outstanding reviews did make me go and watch the movie but I was kind of disappointed I guess the over-hype killed it. In the end it turned out to be a ok movie with nothing extra outstanding as was claimed. I think Munna Bhais were a lot better if compared to 3 Idiots.
I think I would of liked the movie even more if they just took away some of the pissing and toilet sitting scences. It takes away the class of the film. overall it was a good movie.
movie is fantastic mindblowing. Amir really like a 20 yrs boy in this movie. some people intetionally saying such negetive things.... but d monie is very good . everybody must see it. better than gajni....rab ne banadi jodi, even better than every movie Amir is briliant
I have to agree with Anad k. I wouldn't give the movie more than 2/5. The bathrooms scenes and butt salutes were childish and pointless. Aamir Khan's character was too preachy and failed to engage me. The movie could have been cut at least by an hour so poor editing.
"Idiots" made 100 crores in 4 days!!! or …."IDIOTS" is being made out of 100 crore Indians....... where is the math and who is doing the math???? Do the math yourselves…This means in one day movie is making Rs 25 crores....... HOW MANY TICKETS NEED TO BE SOLD IN ONE DAY TO MAKE Rs25 Crores?????..... how many halls are there in India for Hindi cinema???/and what is their sitting capacity... Even if the movie is being screened round the clock still selling tickets worth 25 crores doesn't add upto!!!!!! ……Movie is average... But everyone SHOULD LEARN and APPRECIATE on great MARKeting TALENT of AAMIR Khan on “””” HOW to CREATE "HYPE" for your product””””.......to ENHANCE its SALES...
Thanks for being so kind to award 3 n half rating :) I just loved the chemistry between Aamir and Kareena; well looking at your sarcastic comment it seem you are jealous of Kareena. She is awesome in this movie and very sad to see you comparing her with Deepika/Genelia.....
Very comprehensive and informative review. It seems you are a pro. I saw 3 idiots yesterday.It is excellent and Hirani must be complimented for brining about the limitations of the Indian education system in a very interesting manner. One of the main themes of the movie according to me is “follow your heart” Only problem is that in movies, they are not always able to show all aspects of the problem. For instance, many people come to know what is their cup of tea(enjoy doing) only after they start working(In work, we have the possibility of discovering ourselves) and for many, it is too late by then as India does not have structured career trasnsition. “All is well” is not really so in real life. I have twenty one published articles on the subject which are on my blog- <a href="http://mypyp.wordpress.com">Make your passion your profession</a> which also has quotes on the subject from bollywood, cricket, management and other personalities in the quotable quotes section.
Not only Indian verdict but World Verdict already came n u must be aware that it has proven to be d most successful film of Bollywood ever produced. 400 crores in just 4 days. It's one of d finest movie Bollywood ever produced...go and watch. Aamir is looking even younger than Kareena.
simply great movie... one of the best performance of Amir, educational concept is very true and friendship concept is very touchy. they covered every thing like comedy, emotions, drama etc. I just love this movie 4 and 1/2 out of 5...
I think it is a sexist movie. Do you think they would cast an actress of the same age as Aamir - say Madhuri - in the role of a college girl? Never. But a 44-year old male actor can get away with playing a college kid!!
Before watching the film i thought about amir and how he fits into student character. but after watching movie amir has proved why he is called MR.perfect i can say i watched best movie of the year nothing comes close to this one. dialogs and the character the way they r designed credit has to go to director and amir for giving a wonderful film.
I am not the kind to base my opinion on reviews and opinions - I watched the movie yesterday with a clean slate - and laughed out loud, enjoyed the beautiful scenes and the clever guffaws! Great movie. (and good review Rima - although I read it after watching the movie)
I think it was very difficult to make a movie on a best seller's book. Everybody (part of the movie) has made such a fantastic effort to make such a gr8 movie. I am thankful to them for giving a meanging and definition to "Engineering". I would like to give 5 out 5 to this movie... Best movie of 2009 and an addition in Amir's perfection. That is what he is all about :).
I recently saw the movie and feel that it was just like Taare Zameen Par. The movie used a sense of humor to convey a very deep message. Very entertaining 5/5 rating
The story of the movie really ,is well-chosen and interpreted carefully...it`s the 'story' that has made it worth watching--------rather than a "PAISA WASOOL MOVIE".
From your Comments it is realy clear that you r blindly against Aamir.. Please keep your personal feelings apart and watch the movie..Promo doesn't say the whole story...
If you realy wann ajudge this film...judge it properly..Rating doesnot matter..You can even give 0..but Without watching the movie and seeing the promo dont give any loose comments...
I have seen the Movie.. Being a Great fan Of Sahrukh I am saying that... It should get 5 out of 5.
44 years guy(ameer khan) took this subject to act as like 22 years boy,this itself is an great achievemnt for ameer,i think kareena is not a good selection
In response to Anand.... You seems like a fan of gay "S-khan" (celebrity with identity crisis, who jumps on media to sell himself), otherwise you'd have been sincere in giving your feedback on movie like this.
How often this kind of movie are made? The answer is once in a lifetime...
Anadad... Whts this yaar... think littl different... think fresh yaar... Dont bow down good film like this.
Its a ekdum fundu movie and I liked it. I doesnt matter its someone give 2 or 5. Being Eng. myself, i recomend for all u ppl.... go watch it... have fun. Thats wht matters da most.
and.... Anand bhai... just break the I from movie ... n precede it to ur name... U might find one Idiot in u... N Its great to b idiot than being fool ;)
super hit!!!!!! on seeing u ll laugh and cry as many times at different intervals...! Its a film that contains everything:- super comedy, morality,emtoions... And i ust say its a mutch watch movie.. so much enjoyed. 3 idiots rocks!! My rating 5/5
It is a flop movie. Simply over hyped average product with no real substance. Munna Bhai's were a thousand times more creative and better products. In short it is an average flick...
A beautiful movie. Perfected in all aspects. Yet again the flavour of india is reflected brilliantly . The reviewer seems to have given a low rating (because of his lack oe experience). But 5/5 from my point of view. Way to Amir. (A gift to indian cinema)
Go all ,watch the Movie,just came back from the movie,,,and mind it the movie is for all ,,,,people it is better to watch a movie and get the answers u r trying to find than .....wait to get them answered through life :) Go and Enjoy because All IZ Well
Being an Engineer I hope it reminisces my old days to me, as the same was done by chetan's novel. This film is a great platform to let people understand Engineering students life, in ways that the fun they do and the pressure they live with, no professional course is a perfect combination of fun & pressure as Engineering has , and ofcourse finally in an Engineer words ALL IZZ WELL
I hope aal izz welll!!! (you would get this once you have watched this movie)
i watched a late night show of this movie today and trust me it may well become a cult, especially the dialouges!! Aamir has recreated magic with 3 idiots and its a must watch....enjoy it with your friends and family!!
Hi, I am a big fan of aamir khan. and i am very sure that this movie is super hit. because i know this film story. this is chetan bhagat story. five point some one. it's very good story and the 3 idiots films base on this story. so it's very good movie i am quite sure.
i have read two movie review of 3 idiots.one taran adarsh and now this .taaran gave this movie 4.5 stars and this 3.5stars so tjhis means that 3 idiots rocks.................it will take public with a storm...............everyone id loving the film
Hi.. Thanks for ur review... I have seen the film promo's.. But nothing new i found... as amir khan fan pls dnt give ur rating.. Film music is big minus.. Madhavan n Joshi r impressive since they looks really young..Amir is too old to act in dis role. Nothing to say about Kareena and Amir... Never expected like dis movie frm Amir n Kareena..
Five point someone novel narration is very better dan dis.. lets c how its goes..
Ur review is good.. but i can rate it as 2/5. Indians verdict will cm out very soon..
f*** film